CHAPTER FIFTEEN
PEYTON
I suck in a deep breath and square my shoulders as I walk through the woods. I don’t bother with a flashlight, I know they will find me with ease. I keep my head on a swivel and trudge ahead. I keep walking for a few minutes before feeling the hairs on the back of my neck stand up. My breathing amps up.
They’re watching me!
I can feel their eyes on me. My skin prickles with awareness and I know it's only a matter of time before the chase is on, so I keep calm and act like I don’t know they are near. I continue forward toward a large tree, the second I round the trunk I break out into a sprint and head deeper into the woods. The sound of their footfalls pounding the dirt behind me has me pushing myself harder to escape them. As much as I want to be caught, I refuse to make this easy on them.
“You’re only making this harder on yourself, Bunny!” one of them shouts from behind me, something in his voice seems familiar but I brush it off as I break through some thick shrubs and gasp when I spot a creek up ahead. It isn’t the creek that has my heart pounding inside my chest, it’s the sight of one of my masked men, standing at the edge with his mask glowing bright in the moonlight.
A scream lodges in my throat when a body presses against my back and a hand wraps around my throat from behind. The plastic of his mask rubs against my tender flesh as he speaks low.
“On your knees.” He releases me so I can obey his demand. I sink to the rough ground. I was smart enough to wear sneakers and jeans this time, knowing I would be forced to run and I didn’t want my knees getting busted up and having the guys asking me questions about it tomorrow. “Get my cock out.” I reach up and begin undoing his pants as the other two draw in closer. When his cock springs free, my mouth waters at the sight of it. I don’t need any prompting, I wrap my hand around his shaft and pump. His head rolls back as a groan escapes him. I dart my tongue out and lick him from base to tip, loving the feel of his silky skin. I flick my eyes to meet his as I suck his cock into my mouth.
A whimper escapes me when fingers tangle in my hair and force me to take him deeper. My hands wrap around his thighs as I relax my throat, trying to take him deeper but my gag reflex is an asshole and I begin choking on him. The dark chuckles that sound out around us doesn’t deter me, I know how much they love to hear me. I dart my gaze side to side to see the other two standing there with their dicks in their hands. I reach out and grip each of them, making sure to keep my grip tight and firm, just how they like it.
I alternate between sucking each of them, relishing at the sounds each of them make each time my lips wrap around their cocks.
“Stop!” the one on the right growls. I release them and pull back, gasping for air. I swipe the spit from my chin. “On your feet and strip.” I do as he says and stand. I hate that I’m always the one who is naked but never them, the only thing I get to see is their cocks. It’s not enough they hide their faces from me but they also shield their bodies. My shirt is the first to go, I made sure to wear my black lace set tonight. I kick my sneakers off, then pop the button on my jeans and slowly push them down my legs, loving the feel of their eyes on me the entire time. When I stand before them in nothing but my bra and panties, I suddenly feel unsure.
I haven’t felt like this since the first time, but now suddenly I feel uncertain because in the past week, it isn’t just them who haunt my thoughts. I can’t seem to stop thinking about Van, Hudson and Kye. Those three have somehow wormed themselves inside me and I’m starting to realize I have feelings for them, big feelings.
“On your back,” the one in the middle snaps, drawing me from my thoughts. I do as he demands and force myself to focus on the moment and not dwell on my thoughts. It doesn’t matter what I feel for the other three, I can never have them. “Legs open.” I bend at the knees and open them as wide as I can, they may not be able to see it because of the poor lighting but I can feel I have already soaked through my panties. The one in the middle drops to his knees before me and reaches inside the pocket of his hoodie and pulls out a… is that a chocolate bunny?
“When you leave tonight, you’ll find a gift basket at the back of the church. We borrowed a few gifts, hope you don’t mind?” the one on the left says. My attention is brought back to the guy between my legs when he pushes my panties to the side and unwraps the bunny. My eyes widen when he runs the tip of the bunny ears through my slick folds. I arch off the hard ground.
The one on the right shifts and pushes me up so he can sit behind me, I rest back against his chest as I watch with rapt attention as the bunny continues to circle my clit, drawing a long moan from me. The one behind reaches around and yanks the cups of my bra down and frees my tits—they feel so heavy and are begging to be played with. I cry out when he pinches my nipples between his fingers, a scream ripping out of me a second later when the other pushes the fucking rabbit inside me.
“Fuck!” I hiss.
“Take it,” the one behind me growls as the other guy continues to use the bunny to fuck me. The last guy comes to stand beside us and rubs his pre-cum across my lips.
“Suck it.” I do as I’m commanded and suck him into my mouth. The pressure inside me begins to build but the feeling slowly ebbs away as the damn chocolate starts melting inside me. The moment he yanks it free of my pussy, I whimper around the other’s cock. “Don’t worry, Bunny, he’s gonna eat that cunt clean and make you squirt on his face.”
True to his word, his friend does exactly that, he pushes his hot wet tongue inside my tight little hole. The one behind begins rubbing something on my nipples. I look down to see him using Easter eggs. Oh fuck, they are covering me in chocolate. I gasp and release his cock with a wet pop when the guy between my legs starts rubbing the melted bunny on my ass.
“Don’t worry,” the one behind me purrs. “We’ll lick you clean before we’re finished with you.” His words have heat coiling low in my belly. I can feel my orgasm cresting, sounds tumbling from my lips that would have my mother blushing. The sensations they are dragging out of me are sinister. I’m nothing but an instrument in their hands, they can play me better than I could ever play myself.
“Come on his face, Bunny,” the one on my side growls as he fists himself. His words are my undoing.
My back arches and my scream pierces the air “Fuck!” Before I can control it, I squirt all over him. He opens his mouth and holds my cum in his mouth as the other guy steps forward, lifts his mask and presses his lips to the others’. My eyes widen when I realize they are both drinking my fucking cum!
“Do you like watching them taste you?” the person behind me asks as the other two break their kiss, then slip their masks back into place and look at me.
“Yes,” I answer truthfully.
“Good because we have a surprise for you tonight, Bunny. Turn around and sit on my cock.” I do as he says and straddle his lap, line him up with my entrance and slowly sink down onto his cock, relishing the burn of him stretching me. “Fuck, I missed this cunt,” he forces out when he bottoms out inside me. A hand lands on the center of my back, forcing me to lay flat against his chest. I shiver when I feel the coolness of the lube being massaged into my tight asshole. I’ve become a whore for anal—I never thought I would enjoy it, but now I fucking crave it. The feeling of having two cocks inside me at once is addictive and makes me feel so full.
This time when he slides inside my ass I don’t tense, there is hardly much resistance because I’m so turned on. He tries to go slow but I’m greedy for them. I press back and force him the remainder of the way inside me. We cry out at the feeling. “Fuck, Bunny,” he croaks.
“You feel so good inside me,” I purr as I grind against them.
“You ready for your surprise?” the one beneath me asks. I frown and nod. The guy behind me groans, I peer over my shoulder and my jaw drops.
“Oh, fuck, that is hot,” I mutter as I take in the sight of the last guy sinking his cock into the other—this is something out of one of my wildest fantasies. I never in a million fucking years ever thought I would get to live this out. I have two cocks inside me while one of the guys is being fucked behind me by his friend.